Did you know that registration to Fighter Control is completely free and brings you lots of added features? Find out more....

Indian Fighter deal news

A forum for discussing all things related to MILITARY AVIATION including Military Aviation news. No off-topic discussions here please.
GOOSE

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by GOOSE » Fri Jan 13, 2012 8:57 pm

Great news, if true. :thumb:

hertsman

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by hertsman » Sat Jan 14, 2012 9:17 pm

There have been strong rumours that the Typhoon has won the contest doing the rounds on Indian news and aviation forums. However, part of the story was that Dassault and Cassidian had been summoned to the Indian MOD on Thursday, January 12 - which it seems did not happen. Therefore, the credibility of the leak may have dropped a notch or two, assuming it had any in the first place.

From what I have read on places like The DEW Line and others, the only thing you can be sure of in Indian defence procurements is delay, confusion and conflicting briefings by various government departments. Not that we have anything to be smug about when it comes to procurement of course.

So it's still wait and see, or perhaps wait, wait and see.

hertsman

boff180
Posts: 137
Joined: Sat Nov 28, 2009 10:57 pm
Location: BHX
Contact:

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by boff180 » Sun Jan 15, 2012 8:26 am

I honestly think Rafale is going to win this one from a logistical point of view, the Indians have just made a massive order of Mica missiles.

With all the types of missile they operate, would they want to add another range of weapons such as Asraam, Meteor and IrisT plus western a2g weapons to their inventory. At a time of war, making sure the right missile gets to the right aircraft at the right base would be a nightmare!

Andy
Image

hertsman

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by hertsman » Sun Jan 15, 2012 3:34 pm

Boff180 has a point, India does seem to have a policy of operating multiple defence systems - eg Jaguar, Mig, Sukhoi, Hawk, Mirage, from a variety of suppliers. The MICA's were said to be for their Mirage 2000's, but Rafale is configured for this missile too.

I don't know if this is deliberate policy or has just happened that way. On the one hand multiple suppliers spreads risk; on the other it potentially carries procurement cost penalties and logistical management difficulties. It is certainly appears different from the RAF's doctrine which is to concentrate on Typhoon and F35 to the exclusion of all other front-line fighters, although I guess one expected benefit of the MMRCA project is to replace Jaguar and Mig 21.

I have looked at one or two Indian military aviation blogs, and it is interesting to see the various comments posted. Both fighters have their champions and detractors for a variety of reasons, but a fairly common theme has been the perceived superiority of the Rafale in the ground attack role, and the Typhoon's perceived strength in the air superiority mode. Worries about transfer of technology issues with US elements on Typhoon also get a mention as do manufacturing and logistical support. Some don't care as they think both fighters are pretty good, and some suspect the whole project will get delayed and maybe re-opened to the Russians and Americans again. I conclude Indian military aircraft buffs are not much different to us really - they all have a point of view. Nothing wrong with that.

hertsman

hertsman

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by hertsman » Mon Jan 16, 2012 2:39 pm

The Indian publication, The Economic Times, has quoted senior air force sources as saying the decision is due within the next 10 days. http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/new ... 500839.cms" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

hertsman

hertsman

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by hertsman » Fri Jan 27, 2012 1:07 am

Well 10 days is up.... and not a peep.

Indian defence blogs are in overdrive, many uncomplimentary about their Govt, MoD and procurement processes. More are uncomplimentary about Typhoon, which does not get a good hearing from many of these ordinary Joe's who don't rate it's multi-role credentials or cost. And some are just plain barking!

But none offer any real clue about what is about to be announced, if anything.

hertsman

hertsman

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by hertsman » Tue Jan 31, 2012 1:47 pm

http://www.defensenews.com/article/2012 ... |FRONTPAGE" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Well done Rafale, bad news for Typhoon.

hertsman

RichC

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by RichC » Tue Jan 31, 2012 1:53 pm

They made the right decision in my opinion.

mrlongbow

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by mrlongbow » Tue Jan 31, 2012 3:03 pm

Good choice by India, on the other hand its a shame Typhoon wasnt fully multi-role like the Rafale, would have been a different outcome i guess. A certain part of me does think that Bae will have tried to rip the Indian government off a little, as it does with ours. If that was the case, they deserve to loose.

hertsman

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by hertsman » Tue Jan 31, 2012 3:54 pm

You can tend to read results like this as Rafale good, Typhoon bad. This is not the case of course. These are both good fighters, with Rafale's multi-role credentials more proven than Typhoon right now, added to an overall lower price.

It is bad news for those British factories that would have picked up some work. Another significant Typhoon operator might have spurred further capability enhancing upgrades that could have benefited the RAF, so it's not good news on that front either.

But, on the face of it the Indian's appear to have made a logical choice so you can't blame them for that. They have also saved Rafale's bacon too so at least the production line will now be open long enough for the Royal Navy's order when it comes. :whistle:

hertsman

User avatar
Viper28
Posts: 566
Joined: Sun Oct 11, 2009 9:02 pm

Re: Indian Fighter deal news

Post by Viper28 » Tue Jan 31, 2012 8:58 pm

Rafale - Looks good, goes fast, nothing else matters.... works for me :thumb:

Post Reply

Return to “The Fighter Control Mess”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Sharpy39 and 42 guests