https://www.airforcetimes.com/articles/ ... s-numbered
Are the F-15 Eagle's days numbered? Top generals say maybe
The Air Force is considering retiring its F-15 C and D fighter aircraft and replacing them with F-16s.
In a House Armed Services readiness subcommittee hearing on Wednesday, subcommittee chairman Rep. Joe Wilson, R-S.C., asked Lt. Gen. Scott Rice, director of the Air National Guard, about plans to retire its 236 F-15 C and D Eagle fighters as a cost-saving measure, and filling their role with F-16 Fighting Falcons. Rice confirmed that was under consideration.
Later in the hearing, Rep. Martha McSally, R-Ariz., said that proposal was news to her, and asked Maj. Gen. Scott West, the Air Force's director of current operations and deputy chief of staff for operations, if there had been any decision made on retiring those fighters.
West said nothing was official yet, but said the Air Force is looking for ways to maximize the use of its limited resources, and minimize the number of systems it operates while still accomplishing its mission. West and Rice both said the proposal to retire some F-15s is "predecisional." There was no discussion of the F-15E Strike Eagle.
Rice said the F-16s potentially filling the role vacated by F-15s would receive radar upgrades.
The Air Force is now planning for fiscal 2019, Rice said, but a decision on retiring the F-15C and D would probably not be made this year. Which means those planes would not retire until fiscal 2020 at the earliest.
But replacing the F-15 C and D — a fighter primarily focused on air-to-air operations — with the F-16, which also has air-to-surface capabilities, would raise questions. The F-15 C and D, which entered the Air Force's inventory in 1979, carries up to eight AIM-9 Sidewinder and AIM-120 AMRAAM air-to-air missiles. The F-16, on the other hand, can carry up to six air-to-air missiles or air-to-surface munitions. Both planes carry the M-61A1 20mm multi-barrel cannon, but the F-15 can carry 940 rounds of ammunition to the F-16's 500.
"Clearly, these are two different types of aircraft with different capabilities," Wilson said.
When asked if replacing the F-15 Eagle with the F-16 would have a negative effect on air superiority and present risks, Rice said it can be handled.
"There's a risk in changing any of our force structure decisions," Rice said. But, he added, "there are capabilities we can add and provide on the F-16 that will [fill] a gap as we go into the future. Overall, our readiness and our protection of the U.S. will change, but I think overall, we will be OK."
McSally said that before the F-22 came online, the F-15C was probably the best air-to-air plane around. She compared the F-16 to a "decathlete" that can handle multiple types of combat at a lower cost, but said that even with upgraded radar, it wouldn't have the same air-to-air capabilities as the F-15C.
She also expressed concern about what such a shift would do to aircraft readiness, considering that the Air Force is already facing a pilot shortage.
"We're already in a readiness crisis," McSally said. "If you're now retraining everybody to another aircraft, in the midst of a crisis, that does have a bit of a short-term dip in readiness as well. With us being down to 55 fighter squadrons, we've just got to be careful on how that transition would happen, should this decision come to fruition."
West said there will be some "offline" time as the Air Force moves from one air frame to another. But the advantage the Air Force now enjoys over nations such as China and Russia is lessening, he said, and such a modernization shift must happen sooner rather than later.
Air Force spokeswoman Ann Stefanek later said that eliminating the F-15 C and D is not a done deal. Stefanek noted that the Air Force has also proposed eliminating the A-10 in multiple budgets, but the Warthog has survived.
"We're always looking at force structure options for the future," Stefanek said. "Until it is something that we put in our budget as a proposal, it's just another option that could be pursued. Just because it's an option doesn't mean we'll pursue it."
Did you know that registration to Fighter Control is completely free and brings you lots of added features? Find out more....
Are the F-15 Eagle's days numbered? Top generals say maybe
A forum for discussing all things related to MILITARY AVIATION including Military Aviation news. No off-topic discussions here please.
-
- Posts: 1640
- Joined: Mon Dec 06, 2010 9:19 pm
Are the F-15 Eagle's days numbered? Top generals say maybe
Post by page_verify » Thu Mar 23, 2017 2:17 pm
Return to “The Fighter Control Mess”
Jump to
- ↳ Highlights of the Week
- ↳ Seasonal Photo Challenge
- ↳ Photo Challenge - Autumn 2011
- ↳ Photo Challenge - Winter 2011
- ↳ Photo Challenge - Spring 2012
- Fighter Control Information
- ↳ Forum Rules
- ↳ Fighter Control and Forum Technical Information
- ↳ AeroResource Articles
- ↳ The Newbie Forum
- Fighter Control Community
- ↳ The Fighter Control Mess
- ↳ Military Aviation Memorabilia
- Military Aviation Photography
- ↳ Photography Section Rules and Guidelines
- ↳ Military Aviation Photo Competitions
- ↳ Monthly Photo Competition
- ↳ Specialist Photo Competitions
- ↳ Current Military Photography
- ↳ Airshow & Event Photography
- ↳ Warbirds, Replicas and Nostalgic Photography
- ↳ Aviation Videography
- ↳ Photography Q & A / How to post photos
- Airshows
- ↳ UK Airshows
- ↳ RIAT
- ↳ Farnborough
- ↳ Duxford Shows
- ↳ Yeovilton
- ↳ Cosford
- ↳ Other Airshows & Events
- ↳ Archived Airshows
- ↳ Leuchars
- ↳ Scampton
- ↳ Waddington
- ↳ Shuttleworth
- ↳ European Airshows
- ↳ Rest of the World Airshows
- Spotters Area - Serials and Airfield Logs
- ↳ Recent Serial tie up area
- ↳ Old Serial tie up area
- ↳ South West England
- ↳ RMB Chivenor
- ↳ RNAS Culdrose & Predannack
- ↳ MoD Boscombe Down
- ↳ RAF St Mawgan & Newquay
- ↳ RNAS Yeovilton, Yeovil Westlands & Merryfield
- ↳ Southern England
- ↳ AAC Middle Wallop
- ↳ RAF Benson
- ↳ RAF Brize Norton
- ↳ RAF Fairford
- ↳ Archive Movements 2009 - Present
- ↳ RAF Northolt
- ↳ RAF Odiham
- ↳ West England & Wales
- ↳ RAF Valley & Mona
- ↳ DSAE Cosford
- ↳ RAF Shawbury & Ternhill
- ↳ MOD St Athan
- ↳ Cardiff
- ↳ Lincolnshire, The Midlands & Rutland
- ↳ RAF Coningsby
- ↳ RAF Cranwell & Barkston Heath
- ↳ RAF Waddington
- ↳ RAF Scampton
- ↳ RAF Wittering & Cottesmore
- ↳ East Anglia
- ↳ RAF Wyton
- ↳ Stansted
- ↳ Cambridge Airport
- ↳ AAC Wattisham
- ↳ RAF Lakenheath
- ↳ RAF Mildenhall
- ↳ RAF Marham
- ↳ Northern England
- ↳ BAE Brough
- ↳ RAF Leeming
- ↳ RAF Linton-on-Ouse
- ↳ Warton Aerodrome
- ↳ BAE Woodford
- ↳ Scotland and Ireland
- ↳ RAF Kinloss
- ↳ RAF Leuchars
- ↳ RAF Lossiemouth
- ↳ Prestwick
- ↳ Edinburgh
- ↳ Baldonnel
- ↳ JHC Aldergrove
- ↳ Dublin
- ↳ Shannon
- ↳ All other areas around the UK
- ↳ Europe
- ↳ Germany
- ↳ Other Areas
- ↳ Netherlands
- ↳ Belgium
- ↳ Italy, Malta & Mainland Greece
- ↳ Cyprus & Crete
- ↳ Spain & Portugal
- ↳ Denmark and Norway
- ↳ France
- ↳ North America and the Rest of the World
- ↳ United States of America
- ↳ Canada
- ↳ Rest of the World
- Military Ranges
- ↳ RAF and RN Weapon Ranges
- ↳ Aberporth Range
- ↳ Castlemartin & Manorbier
- ↳ Pembrey Range
- ↳ Donna Nook Range
- ↳ Holbeach Range
- ↳ Wainfleet Range
- ↳ Tain Range
- ↳ Garvie Island
- ↳ Spadeadam & SPACES
- ↳ Lilstock Range
- ↳ Muckleburgh, Sculthorpe & STANTA
- ↳ Sennybridge
- Military Aircraft Flight Simulation
- ↳ Flight Simulator
- ↳ Flight Simulation General Chat
- ↳ FS2004 and FSX Addon Updates
- ↳ FS9 and FSX Repaints
- ↳ Flight Simulator Technical Board
- Heritage, Demobbed & Preservation Groups
- ↳ Newark Air Museum (NAM)
- ↳ Heritage Area
- ↳ RAF Lyneham
- ↳ AAC Dishforth
- ↳ RAF Boulmer
- ↳ RAF Church Fenton & RAF Topcliffe
- ↳ Leconfield
- ↳ The Vulcan XH558 Forum
- Military Aircraft Modelling
- ↳ Modelling Community
- ↳ Technical - Tools and Tips/Walkrounds
- ↳ Work In Progress
- ↳ Gallery
- ↳ FC Modelling Competition
- ↳ Finished Builds
- ↳ Group Builds
- Fighter Control General
- ↳ General Chat
- ↳ General Photography
- Website Promotion & For Sale/Wanted
- ↳ Promotion of your website
- ↳ For Sale and Wanted
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Strike01 and 93 guests